Thursday, December 26, 2013

Women, skip the work vs. family debate, let's go after the archaic corporate model

There is always a lot of heated discussion, passion and judgment on how and what women should be doing when it comes to career and mothering.   The debates and issues play out across the world via television news, television talk shows, movies, books, million dollar websites, blogs and more.  It sure seems like a simple enough question, but like a computer, when you unscrew the case and get a look inside, it sure has a lot of complex circuitry.

Despite our evolution as a society, is it still best for a woman to stay home and raise her children properly?  Forsaking her dreams and never reaching her full potential – denying herself of the happiness that comes from a life lived fully? 

Or, like many,  should she try and do both--work and raise a family?   Of course as every full-time mother knows, this often means traveling on an unsustainable path that will eventually take its toll on either a mother’s mental and physical health, her kids, or her work performance. Sure there is the 50/50 scenario where both mother and father chip in equally, but those kinds of relationships are few and far between.  In most households, research shows that mothers are still the primary caregivers when both parents work.    And for those relationships where there is a true division of work, it means that not only women will be divided between work and home, but the men will be divided too.  Of course this scenario won’t work at all for single parents who have no partner to share the load with. That is a major consideration when half of U.S. marriages end in divorce[1].   

Looking at all these no win situations, one has to wonder if perhaps the best scenario would be to forego raising a family altogether. Unfortunately, that only jeopardizes our future population at a time when it is already in decline[2]. 

As I alluded to in the first paragraph, there really are no great answers when it comes to work versus career for women.  In fact, it often seems like a lose/lose situation. Maybe we aren’t considering something though.  Is the real issue whether or not to stay home, do it all or share?  Could the main issue, the thing that is broken, not be the work versus family, but the fact that our corporate work structure was conceived when only one member of the household, generally the male, worked? It seems to me that our current corporate structure is an archaic and obsolete business model for today’s families—especially for women who are desperately needed in the workforce and have been carrying the burden of  child-rearing since the dawn of time.  The business model needs to evolve into one that is family-friendly, female-friendly and future friendly.  It not only needs to change drastically, but to change quickly.

Yes, we’ve sloppily managed in the past, but the world is changing rapidly.  We are losing a large portion of our workforce as the baby boomers prepare to retire [3]en masse, leaving corporations unmanned and stifled.  Combine this with the fact that women are having fewer children[4], there will only be more of an employee shortage. Let’s not forget that fewer children mean a smaller future client base for corporations looking to prosper years from now.  However, perhaps the most compelling argument of all, at least to corporate America, is the fact that companies with high percentages of women in leadership are more profitable—they have as much as a 35.1% higher return on equity and a 34% better return to shareholders[5]. If women make that much of a difference when only 3-6 % of women hold top positions, imagine what would happen if even more women were in places of leadership.   Sounds like one possible solution to our economic problems to me.

The big headline here is that women’s issues aren’t just a “female problem” anymore.  If there is one thing that everyone gets out of this blog, I hope it is this.  We are at a tipping point where women’s problems are now the country’s problem.   There has never been a more important time in our history for us women to be given equal opportunity and to be given a fair chance in the workplace. If not, we won’t be the only ones suffering anymore.






[1]US Department of Health and Human Services
[2] For the past 12 years,  birthrates have been declining,  hitting an all-time low in 2010 
[3] U.S. Bureau of Labor and Statistics, 2011
[4] Centers for Disease Control (CDC)
[5] Catalyst, The Bottom Line: Connecting Corporate Performance and Gender Diversity (New York: Catalyst, 2004)

No comments: